Skip to main content

Table 8 Performance analysis of best model

From: A radiographic, deep transfer learning framework, adapted to estimate lung opacities from chest x-rays

Population

N

Avg MA- MAE

Lt MA-MAE

Rt MA-

MAE

Avg

F1

Lt

F1

Rt

F1

Avg Pr

Lt Pr

Rt

Pr

Avg Rec

Lt

Rec

Rt

Rec

All Patients

2839

 

0.4769

0.3855

 

62.11

65.21

 

62.24

66.22

 

63.08

65.41

RACE

 Asian

184

0.3971

0.4536

0.3406

64.25

62.72

65.78

65.56

62.57

68.54

65.76

64.67

66.84

 Black

453

0.4626

0.5408

0.3844

64.34

60.98

67.69

65.54

62.75

68.33

65.45

62.69

68.21

 White

1346

0.438

0.4736

0.4025

64.08

63.34

64.82

64.36

63.26

65.45

64.37

63.96

64.78

 Other

739

0.4196

0.4579

0.3813

62.00

60.37

63.64

63.39

60.83

65.95

62..65

61.43

63.87

 Unknown

117

0.4039

0.4510

0.3569

64.45

60.73

68.16

65.59

61.45

69.73

65.81

62.39

69.23

SEX

 Male

1625

0.4295

0.4937

0.3652

63.16

60.07

66.25

64.03

60.63

67.43

63.75

61.16

66.33

 Female

1214

0.4129

0.4482

0.3775

66.94

65.68

68.20

67.56

65.64

69.48

67.58

66.63

68.53

COVID

 COVID +ve

1513

0.4216

0.4783

0.3649

61.58

55.40

67.76

62.44

69.64

66.32

62.12

55.71

68.53

 COVID -ve

1326

0.4584

0.5262

0.3907

67.44

69.46

65.43

67.98

56.29

68.59

67.87

70.58

65.16

  1. The final model was comprised of a fine-tuned ResNet-50 architecture with no ROI segmentation and an undersampling scheme. The performance analysis is performed across race, sex and COVID-19 status. Abbreviations used in the table include Pr = Precision, Rec = Recall, F1 = F1 score, and MA-MAE = Macro-averaged Mean Absolute Error